The Trinity Churchyard at 74 Trinity Place, near Wall Street and Broadway, includes tombstones and memorials dating back as far as 1681. One of the largest monuments in the churchyard is the Soldiers’ Monument in honor of Revolutionary War soldiers held in captivity in the old Sugar House in New York City and thought to be buried at Trinity. The inscription said, “In memory of the officers and soldiers of the revolution ho died in British captivity in the city of New York, many of whom are buried in the North Part of Trinity Church yard opposite Pine Street.
The claim those prisoners are buried in Trinity Churchyard is disputed by Charles I. Bushnell, who argued in 1863 that Trinity Church would not have accepted them because it supported Great Britain. The controversy was related to a proposal to build a public street through the churchyard.
Although his actual burial site is unknown, a bronze plaque commemorates Francis Lewis, a signer of the Declaration of Independence. He is the only signer buried in Manhattan.
The restored epitaph for the founder of New York’s first newspaper, William Bradford, is one of the most interesting in the churchyard: “Being quite worn out with Old age and labor he left this mortal State in the lively Hopes of a better Immortality. Reader reflect how soon you’ll quit the Stage…”
One of the churchyard’s most popular sites is Alexander Hamilton‘s tomb. In addition to being the namesake and main character of the Broadway hit Hamilton, he was the first Secretary of the Treasury, founded The Bank of New York and the U.S. Mint, and was the youngest framer of the Constitution. Elizabeth Schuyler Hamilton lies next to Alexander’s grave. Alexander Hamilton’s sister-in-law, Angelica Schuyler Church, is buried in the Livingston Family Vault. Her maternal grandmother was born a Livingston.