
St. Joseph’s Parish was founded by Bishop John Dubois in 1829. At the time St. Joseph’s Parish began, the population of New York, numbering 203,000, was concentrated in the southern half of Manhattan. Early church records indicate that St. Joseph’s first congregants were predominantly Irish-Americans.
After several years in a rented hall at Grove and Christopher Streets, the cornerstone of the present church was laid on June 10, 1833. The church was designed by John Doran in the Greek Revival style, but it has been extensively renovated over the years. Two fires, one in 1855 and the other in 1885, caused extensive damage to the interior. Renovations after the second fire were supervised by Arthur Crooks. The interior of the church was restored in 1972. At the time, a fresco of the Transfiguration, after Raphael’s original in the Vatican, was discovered under layers of paint and restored. Structural restoration work was performed in 1991–1992.